Brian R Pritchard Motion Picture and Film Archive Consultant

 

 

 

 

 

 

CUEING METHODS

The article on Grading/Timing might also be of interest to you

Cueing  is the method we use to transfer the results of grading to the printing machine.  Whatever method we use for grading we will have two pieces of information we have to pass to the printing machine.  “HOW MUCH LIGHT AND WHEN” The “how much light” is the result and purpose of our grading.  The “when” is the point in the film when we want to give that particular amount of light. The “when” can be determined and communicated in many ways.  The very first method was by the printing operator feeling for a join and making an exposure change at about the right time.  This was not terribly satisfactory nor convenient because if there were a scene change   without a join then he would not know where to make the change.  The next step was to cut a notch at the join so that the operator could more easily feel the light change.  It also meant that if you did not want a change at every join or wanted a change in between joins you could have one. Once the notch   became established it was not long before different printing machine manufacturers began inventing systems to automate the light change mechanism.

 

Bell and Howell  on their D and J printers moved the notch to 6 frames after the scene change and used the notch to operate a micro switch (often called an interrupter).  That micro switch operated an electromagnet   that was connected to the shutter operating mechanism via a calibrated lever (numbered from 1 to 22).  The mechanics were arranged so that the operator could pre-set the light value and when the micro switch was triggered that value was transferred to the shutter.  The operator then pre-selected the next light value. 

 

The grading information was written on a card with each value in a box.  The machine had a pointer that moved down the card every time the micro switch was operated. Because the operator only had the time between light changes to set the next value it was normal practice to indicate fast changes. The fast change was sometimes a box around the light or a line down the side of the lights. Debrie printers and others used the notch cut at the scene change.  The Debrie notch is longer than the B&H. Because the micro switch is above the gate a rotary switch is used to delay the light change until the correct frame is in the gate.

 

            Debrie Notcher Left;  Bell & Howell Notcher below.

 

                                             Bell and Howell Notch

 

 

The notch was the standard method for cueing films; you will often find that the negative will have B&H notches on the one side and Debrie notches on the other side.  This is because the answer and show print would have been printed on a continuous printer such as the B&H Model D for speed and when the Fine Grain Duplicating Positive would be made on a Debrie step printer for maximum picture quality and steadiness and to avoid perforation   pitch   problems you get on a rotary printer when making two stage dupes.  Normally the negative is short pitch and the positive is long pitch because they are lying on top of each other on the rotary printer’s main sprocket.  When you are making a Fine Grain Duplicating Positive and then a duplicate negative on a rotary printer they would both need to be first long and then short pitch for the two stages. The solution is to use a step printer.

It was standard practice in laboratories to pre-notch negatives particularly feature films.  Every scene in the film would be notched before the film passed to the grader, usually where there was a cut-in dissolve a notch would be put at the start of the optical   and another one at the mid point of the dissolve.  Pre-notching a film speeded up the work of the grader and allowed him to get on with the grading   and not have to notch the scenes as he went along.  It did mean that sometimes you could have a lot of unnecessary light changes. You can see that 'Pure Hell at St Trinians' had a lot of light 13’s.    The disadvantage of notches is that you are physically damaging the edge of the film weakening the area close to the perforations.  Many old and sometimes not so old negatives have tears emanating from the notches.

Lawley introduced the Lawley Clip to avoid the use of notches.  The Lawley clip was a nickel-silver staple that in 35mm was wrapped around the film between the perforations.  The staples were used to activate a pair of contacts.  Each light change required two staples because besides the first clip causing the light change the second clip also gave the light value that was determined by its position.  This system had the great advantage that there were no charts, cards or bands to lose.  The disadvantage was that it was (and is) quite difficult to remove clips even though Lawley provided a de-clipper.  The easiest method, if you have nerves of steel and a steady hand, is to use two knife blades to open up the clip, but do not practice on a valuable negative. If the grader needed to alter the light value he had to remove a clip.  The clips can also damage other makes of printing machine particularly the gate.

 

Debrie introduced a frame count type of system.  It is some times known as a long chart.  The film was graded on a special Debrie synchroniser table with a roll of cardboard or parchment film, that ran through the synchroniser at 1/8 the speed of the negative. Every time the grader wanted a light change he used a punch to cut a small rectangular hole in the chart.  When the negative was printed the chart ran through a head on the printer that had feelers to detect the holes and operate the light change. The system had the advantage that there were no notches in the negative but had the disadvantage that the table was required for grading or regrading so making a correction quite time consuming. Vinten  used a similar system that had a 70mm wide parchment roll with holes punched in it to record the value of the light change.  The chart roll was cut on a special grading   machine that had a wheel with 21 cut outs. In each of the cut out was a single frame of negative that printed at that light.  The grader compared each scene with the sample frames and matched it to the one that looked most similar.  That gave the grading light that was then cut into the chart.  The chart moved at 1/100th the speed of the roll of negative. Vinten in some of their machines in America used a metal staple to make the light changes.  It was a single staple but apparently suffered from the fault that the printing machine sometimes missed a staple and then the rest of the roll would have wrong lights.

 

 

 

 

The next system to be introduced was the RFQ .  This was a small adhesive aluminum tab that was stuck on the film when a change was required.  The printing machine   was equipped with a metal detector probe that detected the tab as it passed close to the probe.  The RFQ stands for Radio Frequency Cue   because the electronics used radio frequencies.  This system has the advantage that it does not damage the film but has the disadvantage that cleaning machines can cause the cues to come unstuck from the film

 

In recent years frame count cueing has been introduced.